SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 17
The Kantian Peace
Relevancy Globalization Greater interactions Superpower status Power shape global system Theory informs policy Leaders are paying attention, so shouldn’t we then get it right?
“And now America faces a third opportunity to provide the kind of lasting peace that for so long eluded us. At this defining moment, I know where I stand. I stand for American engagement in support of a democratic peace, a peace that can secure for the next generation a world free from war, free from conflict.”—George H. W. Bush (1992)
“Ultimately, the best strategy to ensure our security and to build a durable peace is to support the advance of democracy elsewhere. Democracies don't attack each other.” –Bill Clinton (1994)
“And the reason why I'm so strong on democracy is democracies don't go to war with each other.  And the reason why is the people of most societies don't like war, and they understand what war means.... I've got great faith in democracies to promote peace.” –George W. Bush (2004)
Kant’s Perpetual Peace Act “only on that maxim through which you can at the same time will that it should become a universal law.”—Immanuel Kant
Background on Kant Basis for domestic & international peace Hobbesian view of state of nature Create system with checks “Perpetual Peace”:  Two Stages
Perpetual Peace:  Stage One Realistic peace agreements No standing armies No excessive credit system Relevant today? Respect state sovereignty Restraints to warfare
Why “civilize” warfare? Why limits: Spies? Assassination? Torture? Treatment of prisoners? Target civilians?
Stage Two: Constitutional Republics   Constitution Separation of Powers  Respect for law Representative government Citizen consent  caution Personal risk Personal resources National debt
Stage Two:  Federation of Free States  Rules of respect & cooperation Sovereignty Peace & security  Transfer domestic rule of law to international level Universal norms
Stage Two:  Hospitality Respect foreign visitors Greater interactions Commerce No imperialism
End Game Creates international norms Peace is in self-interest of all NOTE:  not a“democratic” peace, instead institutions + liberal values
Reflection Can these traits only be found in liberal democracies? If we buy into the Kantian peace, are we then obligated to actively create more democracies for the greater good?
Other Views of Democratic Peace Satisfaction Accounts Satisfied individuals Shared interests with other democracies Constitutional Accounts Deliberation slows decision-making Open debate
More Normative Accounts Internalized norms Shared norms Elections Avoid voter backlash Interdependence Greater trade (self interest) Greater interaction

More Related Content

What's hot

What role does liberalism play within security studies
What role does liberalism play within security studiesWhat role does liberalism play within security studies
What role does liberalism play within security studies
Calum Rogers
 
02a types of international conflict
02a types of international conflict02a types of international conflict
02a types of international conflict
fatima d
 
Collective security
Collective securityCollective security
Collective security
shreeshona
 

What's hot (20)

Causes of war
Causes of warCauses of war
Causes of war
 
Types of war
Types of warTypes of war
Types of war
 
War and its types.
War and its types.War and its types.
War and its types.
 
Lecture #4: Conflict, War, and Terrorism
Lecture #4:  Conflict, War, and TerrorismLecture #4:  Conflict, War, and Terrorism
Lecture #4: Conflict, War, and Terrorism
 
Political Science 7 – International Relations - Power Point #10
Political Science 7 – International Relations - Power Point #10Political Science 7 – International Relations - Power Point #10
Political Science 7 – International Relations - Power Point #10
 
Introduction to Global Society
Introduction to Global SocietyIntroduction to Global Society
Introduction to Global Society
 
What role does liberalism play within security studies
What role does liberalism play within security studiesWhat role does liberalism play within security studies
What role does liberalism play within security studies
 
Political Science 5 – Western Political Thought - Power Point #10
Political Science 5 – Western Political Thought - Power Point #10Political Science 5 – Western Political Thought - Power Point #10
Political Science 5 – Western Political Thought - Power Point #10
 
02a types of international conflict
02a types of international conflict02a types of international conflict
02a types of international conflict
 
Causes of war
Causes of warCauses of war
Causes of war
 
International Conflict
International Conflict International Conflict
International Conflict
 
War and peace
War and peaceWar and peace
War and peace
 
Collective security
Collective securityCollective security
Collective security
 
War and Peace in the 21st century, or Will the World Collapse in the Next 10-...
War and Peace in the 21st century, or Will the World Collapse in the Next 10-...War and Peace in the 21st century, or Will the World Collapse in the Next 10-...
War and Peace in the 21st century, or Will the World Collapse in the Next 10-...
 
Speech by former US Secretary of State Madeleine Albright on Democracy and Se...
Speech by former US Secretary of State Madeleine Albright on Democracy and Se...Speech by former US Secretary of State Madeleine Albright on Democracy and Se...
Speech by former US Secretary of State Madeleine Albright on Democracy and Se...
 
Liberal internationalism
Liberal internationalismLiberal internationalism
Liberal internationalism
 
Collection of Economic Freedom Quotes (Curated by Christopher Allen)
Collection of Economic Freedom Quotes (Curated by Christopher Allen)Collection of Economic Freedom Quotes (Curated by Christopher Allen)
Collection of Economic Freedom Quotes (Curated by Christopher Allen)
 
The Absolute Truths
The Absolute TruthsThe Absolute Truths
The Absolute Truths
 
War and Warfare - An Overview
War and Warfare - An Overview War and Warfare - An Overview
War and Warfare - An Overview
 
Political Science 7 – International Relations - Power Point #5
Political Science 7 – International Relations - Power Point #5Political Science 7 – International Relations - Power Point #5
Political Science 7 – International Relations - Power Point #5
 

Similar to The democratic peace

Lecture1. Realism and Liberalism
Lecture1. Realism and LiberalismLecture1. Realism and Liberalism
Lecture1. Realism and Liberalism
Anna Dekaltchouk
 
Liberalism and IRDevelopment of INR – Week 5Kant Essay o.docx
Liberalism and IRDevelopment of INR – Week 5Kant Essay o.docxLiberalism and IRDevelopment of INR – Week 5Kant Essay o.docx
Liberalism and IRDevelopment of INR – Week 5Kant Essay o.docx
jesssueann
 
2. theoretical foundations of global governance
2. theoretical foundations of global governance2. theoretical foundations of global governance
2. theoretical foundations of global governance
Helen Sakhan
 

Similar to The democratic peace (18)

Surname 1 namecourseinstitutiondatewill the spread of
Surname  1 namecourseinstitutiondatewill the spread of Surname  1 namecourseinstitutiondatewill the spread of
Surname 1 namecourseinstitutiondatewill the spread of
 
Theoriesof ir
Theoriesof irTheoriesof ir
Theoriesof ir
 
Lecture no. 8 liberalism
Lecture no. 8 liberalismLecture no. 8 liberalism
Lecture no. 8 liberalism
 
Political science part x
Political science part xPolitical science part x
Political science part x
 
3.1. War Quiz
3.1. War Quiz3.1. War Quiz
3.1. War Quiz
 
Immanuel Kant
Immanuel KantImmanuel Kant
Immanuel Kant
 
Lecture1. Realism and Liberalism
Lecture1. Realism and LiberalismLecture1. Realism and Liberalism
Lecture1. Realism and Liberalism
 
Global Issues - International Policy
Global Issues - International PolicyGlobal Issues - International Policy
Global Issues - International Policy
 
Liberalism and IRDevelopment of INR – Week 5Kant Essay o.docx
Liberalism and IRDevelopment of INR – Week 5Kant Essay o.docxLiberalism and IRDevelopment of INR – Week 5Kant Essay o.docx
Liberalism and IRDevelopment of INR – Week 5Kant Essay o.docx
 
Security
SecuritySecurity
Security
 
Eternal peace-of-kant
Eternal peace-of-kantEternal peace-of-kant
Eternal peace-of-kant
 
Political Science 7 – International Relations - Power Point #6
Political Science 7 – International Relations - Power Point #6Political Science 7 – International Relations - Power Point #6
Political Science 7 – International Relations - Power Point #6
 
Liberalism
LiberalismLiberalism
Liberalism
 
humr5131_h-rights-in-intern-rel-2014.ppt
humr5131_h-rights-in-intern-rel-2014.ppthumr5131_h-rights-in-intern-rel-2014.ppt
humr5131_h-rights-in-intern-rel-2014.ppt
 
Global Issues - International Security
Global  Issues - International  SecurityGlobal  Issues - International  Security
Global Issues - International Security
 
Sir221 2016 ft unit 1 - actors in ir + realism theory(1)
Sir221 2016 ft   unit 1 - actors in ir + realism theory(1)Sir221 2016 ft   unit 1 - actors in ir + realism theory(1)
Sir221 2016 ft unit 1 - actors in ir + realism theory(1)
 
2. theoretical foundations of global governance
2. theoretical foundations of global governance2. theoretical foundations of global governance
2. theoretical foundations of global governance
 
IR Lec 3 (1) (1).pptx
IR Lec 3 (1) (1).pptxIR Lec 3 (1) (1).pptx
IR Lec 3 (1) (1).pptx
 

More from jsewell

Ch 16 - ecologism (shallow)
Ch 16  - ecologism (shallow)Ch 16  - ecologism (shallow)
Ch 16 - ecologism (shallow)
jsewell
 
Ch 16 - ecologism (deep)
Ch 16  - ecologism (deep)Ch 16  - ecologism (deep)
Ch 16 - ecologism (deep)
jsewell
 
Chapter 6 (day 2)
Chapter 6 (day 2)Chapter 6 (day 2)
Chapter 6 (day 2)
jsewell
 
Lecture 1 -power, theory, & overview
Lecture 1 -power, theory, & overviewLecture 1 -power, theory, & overview
Lecture 1 -power, theory, & overview
jsewell
 
Chapter 5
Chapter 5Chapter 5
Chapter 5
jsewell
 
Chapter 3
Chapter 3Chapter 3
Chapter 3
jsewell
 
Chapter2 (day 2)
Chapter2 (day 2)Chapter2 (day 2)
Chapter2 (day 2)
jsewell
 
Introducing the constitution
Introducing the constitutionIntroducing the constitution
Introducing the constitution
jsewell
 
Chapter2
Chapter2Chapter2
Chapter2
jsewell
 
Chapter1
Chapter1Chapter1
Chapter1
jsewell
 

More from jsewell (10)

Ch 16 - ecologism (shallow)
Ch 16  - ecologism (shallow)Ch 16  - ecologism (shallow)
Ch 16 - ecologism (shallow)
 
Ch 16 - ecologism (deep)
Ch 16  - ecologism (deep)Ch 16  - ecologism (deep)
Ch 16 - ecologism (deep)
 
Chapter 6 (day 2)
Chapter 6 (day 2)Chapter 6 (day 2)
Chapter 6 (day 2)
 
Lecture 1 -power, theory, & overview
Lecture 1 -power, theory, & overviewLecture 1 -power, theory, & overview
Lecture 1 -power, theory, & overview
 
Chapter 5
Chapter 5Chapter 5
Chapter 5
 
Chapter 3
Chapter 3Chapter 3
Chapter 3
 
Chapter2 (day 2)
Chapter2 (day 2)Chapter2 (day 2)
Chapter2 (day 2)
 
Introducing the constitution
Introducing the constitutionIntroducing the constitution
Introducing the constitution
 
Chapter2
Chapter2Chapter2
Chapter2
 
Chapter1
Chapter1Chapter1
Chapter1
 

The democratic peace

  • 2. Relevancy Globalization Greater interactions Superpower status Power shape global system Theory informs policy Leaders are paying attention, so shouldn’t we then get it right?
  • 3. “And now America faces a third opportunity to provide the kind of lasting peace that for so long eluded us. At this defining moment, I know where I stand. I stand for American engagement in support of a democratic peace, a peace that can secure for the next generation a world free from war, free from conflict.”—George H. W. Bush (1992)
  • 4. “Ultimately, the best strategy to ensure our security and to build a durable peace is to support the advance of democracy elsewhere. Democracies don't attack each other.” –Bill Clinton (1994)
  • 5. “And the reason why I'm so strong on democracy is democracies don't go to war with each other. And the reason why is the people of most societies don't like war, and they understand what war means.... I've got great faith in democracies to promote peace.” –George W. Bush (2004)
  • 6. Kant’s Perpetual Peace Act “only on that maxim through which you can at the same time will that it should become a universal law.”—Immanuel Kant
  • 7. Background on Kant Basis for domestic & international peace Hobbesian view of state of nature Create system with checks “Perpetual Peace”: Two Stages
  • 8. Perpetual Peace: Stage One Realistic peace agreements No standing armies No excessive credit system Relevant today? Respect state sovereignty Restraints to warfare
  • 9. Why “civilize” warfare? Why limits: Spies? Assassination? Torture? Treatment of prisoners? Target civilians?
  • 10. Stage Two: Constitutional Republics Constitution Separation of Powers Respect for law Representative government Citizen consent  caution Personal risk Personal resources National debt
  • 11. Stage Two: Federation of Free States Rules of respect & cooperation Sovereignty Peace & security Transfer domestic rule of law to international level Universal norms
  • 12. Stage Two: Hospitality Respect foreign visitors Greater interactions Commerce No imperialism
  • 13. End Game Creates international norms Peace is in self-interest of all NOTE: not a“democratic” peace, instead institutions + liberal values
  • 14. Reflection Can these traits only be found in liberal democracies? If we buy into the Kantian peace, are we then obligated to actively create more democracies for the greater good?
  • 15.
  • 16. Other Views of Democratic Peace Satisfaction Accounts Satisfied individuals Shared interests with other democracies Constitutional Accounts Deliberation slows decision-making Open debate
  • 17. More Normative Accounts Internalized norms Shared norms Elections Avoid voter backlash Interdependence Greater trade (self interest) Greater interaction